Kickstarter Lesson #24: Backer Engagement

26 March 2013 | 10 Comments

Many of this week’s Kickstarter Lessons will be about reaching out to people (bloggers, reviewers, etc) to attract new backers to your project. But even more important than that is to engage the backers you already have–after all, those are the people who already already buy in to what you’re doing, and thus they make the best evangelizers of your product. Plus, backers (especially early backers) have the opportunity to offer you feedback to improve your product.

I was recently discussing this concept with backer, friend, and Stonemaier Games board member Morten, and after reading his perspective on backer outreach, I asked him to share it on this blog so other creators can benefit from it. Morten uses the story of Viticulture as a framework to help you see the impact that backer engagement can have on a project. I’ll let Morten take it from here:

Kickstarter Lesson #24: Backer Engagement

How do you get complete strangers to help improve your product and evangelize it? How do you do this without any relevant track record or platform?

Sounds impossible, doesn’t it? But Jamey Stegmaier actually achieved this with the Viticulture Kickstarter campaign. I’m one of the people who paid money while spending lots of hours helping out, and here I’ll describe why I did this, in the hope that it’ll help you to achieve the same results with your Kickstarter campaign.

MortenEngage the backers

In August last year I was on a trip to Tuscany where I visited a small vineyard and bought some of their wine. Roughly a week after coming back I noticed the Kickstarter campaign for the board game Viticulture that’s about running a vineyard in Tuscany. This coincidence caught my attention, but the designers were unknown to me and complete nobodies in the board game business, so I asked to see the rules for the game.

Jamey didn’t respond to my request to see the rules in the obvious ways such as simply sending me the rules or keeping them secret out of fear of idea theft. Instead he very swiftly engaged me by being open about his fear of a rules document without illustrations and nice layout deterring potential backers, and he asked for my opinion. We had a brief exchange where he was quick to respond and the result was that Jamey posted the rules.

So Jamey got me hooked by engaging me, sharing his thoughts and listening to what I said. During the following days he continued to feed me the line and sinker.

Let the backers be part of the dream

I downloaded the rules and read them. As a force of habit I noted typos and ways to improve the text, and since Jamey had come off as a nice guy who was genuinely interested in input from backers, wrote down my suggestions for changes and sent them to him. Within the same day he had incorporated my changes and reposted the updated rules with a public “thank you” to me.

At this point I had become emotionally invested in the Kickstarter, I felt that I was actually a part of the project, and I increased my initial pledge from $5 to $69. Spurred on by my suggestions being incorporated so quickly, I continued working on the rule text throught the campaign.

Within every hobby there are enthusiasts like me, who dream of making a real product, and such people will work for free just for the feeling of being a part of making a product.

Have the backers evangelize

The next step of my involvement came when a print’n’play version of Viticulture was made available to the most active backers and to anybody else who asked for it. I printed it out and scrounged parts from other games to make a prototype of Viticulture.

After playing some games I wrote a review and posted it to, which is arguably the most important board game site with user generated content. Another backer did the same. Both reviews were positive and suddenly Viticulture had some real and positive information from independent sources available at a site frequented by the core of the potential backers.

The backers of Viticulture were now evangelizing the game. “I’m going over to BGG [] to stir up some eyes” is an example of a comment posted by a backer.

Let the backers influence the product

After playing the game and writing the review Jamey and I ended up discussing the mechanics and design of the game, and it turned out that he was open to make tweaks based on input from backers. At this point we were exchanging mails on a daily basis and I was impressed by the amount of attention that Jamey gave me and I felt that he really listened to what I said.

All of this further reinforced the feeling of being part of the dream of making a game and thus got me even more invested in the Kickstarter.

The end result

At the end I had helped tweak the game mechanics, improve the quality of the written rules and evangelized the game, and not only did I do this for free, I actually paid $180 for the privilege.

I have also spent time helping out with the next Stonemaier game, Euphoria, I have signed up to work for free on an advisory board that has been set up and I’m now writing this blog post.

You might think that I’m crazy actually paying money to work for a commercial company, but from my point of view it hasn’t been work, it has been a great chance for doing something I love and live out a little part of my dream of becoming a game designer.

I used the term “commercial company” and while the techniques discussed here can work for a commercial company it will work much better if the backers feel that they’re helping out a nice guy who’s working like crazy to make his dream, which is shared by the backers, come true. In that regard Jamey succeeded. I didn’t feel that I was helping Stonemaier Games, I felt that I was helping out a passionate and genuinely nice guy.

Lessons learned

If you play your cards right you’ll have people paying to let them work for you, and it’ll have the added benefit that you’ll get honest feedback, which is much better than the won’t-hurt-your-feelings-feedback usually provided by friends:

  1. Use any opportunity to engage the backers and make them feel like they’re part of the dream.
  2. Be transparent: Share your thoughts and considerations. Tell backers the reasoning behind your decisions.
  3. Launch with a nonfinal product and ask for input. Ask questions in project updates, emails, the comment section and by posting polls. Act swiftly on the answers and let the backers have influence – though not so much influence that the project appears to be without a clear vision (see Lesson #20).
  4. Ask for help: In a Kickstarter of a reasonable size there are bound to be backers with useful skills.
  5. Be someone that backers want to help: Let your passion for the project ooze from your communication and act in a friendly manner – even in the face of trolls and unreasonable feelings of entitlement.

Finally I’d recommend setting up an advisory board of the most dedicated backers, so that you’ll have help after the end of your campaign, and someone to help you out with your next project.


Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts, Morten! If other backers (of any project) or project creators have some thoughts to add, feel free to do so in the comments below.

Also see this post about the importance of clarity on backer polls.

Next: Reddit

Leave a Comment

10 Comments on “Kickstarter Lesson #24: Backer Engagement

  1. Every person I have ever met has some sort of dream or project that they haven’t been able to accomplish yet. Like the article says, helping you with your project is letting them live or learning about how to achieve their own dream. The big question is how do you attract people that will work for free?

    My answer would be first you work for free helping others achieve their goals and dreams, especially projects that are like what you want to work on. Give your honest feedback on a book that someone has written, or write up notes on a new dating app that they are creating. These projects will help sharpen your eye about issues with projects and teach you how to give and receive feedback.

    Jamey, do you have any other ideas on how to attract these types of people?

    1. Daniel: I think that ties into my article about “10 Daily Actions to Build a Crowd,” which is largely focused on adding value to other people. During a Kickstarter campaign itself, if you’re trying to inspire people to try out the game or proofread the rulebook, I think it helps to make them feel like they’re part of something special, something bigger than themselves.

  2. Engaging with backers is very important but also it is very rewarding! I viewed every new backer as a potential new friend. For our first campaign we sent personal thank you notes to each of our 766 backers up until the final 24 hours when we were just not able to keep up. It was fun sending them personal notes, asking questions, and have some back and forth. I think if you are going to be a Kickstarter creator you should go into the campaign with some excitement about getting to know your backers. We had a great time doing this and made some new friends in the process.

  3. @Yvonne, sorry I didn’t see your post until today. Maybe I didn’t explain it properly in my post, but my post makes two points and the least interesting one of them is that “engaging with the backers can help them feel they have more of a stake in the project and a vested interest in helping it become successfully funded too.”

    Instead my main point is that by playing into some of the backer’s dream of creating a product like yours, you can get them to work (for free) on improving your product. Not because they want to help your product be successfully funded, but because they can live out a little bit of their dream of becoming board game designers (replace “game” with your product type).

    By doing this Jamey for example got a lot of free labor for doing something as boring as proof reading of the rules. Furthermore you get a group people (such as the advisory board that StoneMaier Games setup) that will spend countless hours helping you improve your next product (again for free).

  4. Thanks for all the information. I can see how engaging with the backers can help them feel they have more of a stake in the project and a vested interest in helping it become successfully funded too. ;)

© 2020 Stonemaier Games